Search for:

PLATO & ARISTOTLE ON POLITICS.   Term Paper ID:24720 Click to get this paper Essay Subject: Compares views on ideal govt., justice, virtue, education.... More... 6 Pages / 1350 Words 2 sources, 14 Citations, MLA Format $24.00 Return to List of Papers Paper Abstract: Compares views on ideal govt., justice, virtue, education. Paper Introduction: Justice is a function not of actions or behavior as such--and by implication not of material experience more generally--but rather of the just conceptualization, which must precede the just action if the action and the one who performs it are to be considered authentically just, either by oneself or by others: [Justice] . . . is not a matter of external behaviour, but of the inward self . . . . The just man . . . sets his house in order, by self-mastery and discipline . . . . Only when he has linked these parts together in well-tempered harmony . . . will he be ready to go about whatever he may have to do, whether it be making money . . . or the affairs of state (Plato 141-2). The mechanism of harmony in personal and civic relationships is political education and desire for wisdom, a "constant passion for a Text of the Paper: The entire text of the paper is shown below. However, the text is somewhat scrambled. We want to give you as much information as we possibly can about our papers and essays, but we cannot give them away for free. In the text below you will find that while disordered, many of the phrases are essentially intact. From this text you will be able to get a solid sense of the writing style, the concepts addressed, and the sources used in the research paper. conception of politics of the art of ruling toAristotle's How generally but rather of thejust conceptualization which must precede but of the inward self The just man sets making money or the affairs of that reality which enduresfor ever basis for the community's depositingsovereignty with the ruler Implicit in with a view toward attaining the highest kind and any rate it must belearned by means their way through all these matters state is not shaped according to the theexternal life of the community because governance is a creating and nurturing the virtuesnecessary whether the Rulers be one or more they will the same stringent obligations to virtue as thewash of educationand training Internalized temperament not of virtue but of things Governanceaccording to a temperament of ambition is defined of the polis comes at the price of who may not compete among themselves but whoinevitably and always of inherited wealth Plato If oligarchy is faulty because it suited for governance But because the latter kind of is faulty because it concentrates power in a ruler in the ruler'sjudgment but on monarchy as a form of government In building his argument which virtue can be arrived too of the need to that of the good citizen of the best city must a city on the pattern of aristocracy or kingship and the habits of virtue seems very much inkeeping results not about ideal forms conclusions as Plato as regardsgood and structure reveal about political virtue that is meant to illustrate meaning by wayof right forms Aristotle Aristotle locates politicalsovereignty in governance by take three subsidiary types of constitution and each closest in conception to Plato's philosopher kingship Aristotle Among the wrong constitutional forms aimed at at the king's self-interest Oligarchy meant to serve virtue can be aneffective strategy of governance auniversal principle is associated with justice and the good Aristotle Both Plato and Aristotle are concerned to of the ideal of justice Baker Oxford Oxford U P Plato The as a politicalcommunity where justice and the Justice is a function not of actions or eitherby oneself or by others Justice is harmony will he be ready to go about whatever he a constant passion for anyknowledge that the philosopher-king whose commitmentto virtue and its laws is that derives its value for us sound education has made the rulers thatmake society coherent and give it has a stronger chance to conceptualization of ideal politicalforms and constitution for so long as they Plato tosuggest quite against historical praxis observation of the principles of virtue which is a function competitive and ambitioustemperament answering to the Spartan constitution and then War willbe it constant occupation and military the Good Oligarchic governance is pernicious by reason lower class by reason of indolence education having an equal voice tramples notions of virtue and goodnessbecause the The people mayidentify with the despot but sheep'sclothing The temperament of the despot is passionate ideal forms Aristotle on the other hand analyzes seethe importance of education of youth that is taken used to make a good man Aristotle Aristotle continues just the same means by which a man becomes the same as those which make a good statesman or and political virtue is identified in aconceptualization and approximation of ideal virtue that is Aristotle hislogical method differs from that of shape that politicalcommunity might take As a consequence Aristotle the common interest or consider only the personal interest of aims atbenefiting the common interest right constitutional forms are the following Kingship government by the masses with good and thereforeperversions of the right forms are the is directly antithetical to constitutional government Aristotle Having a project ofuniversalizing his political analysis in the sphere of politics is justice general temperament of politicalanalysis But they structure of the ideal of justice virtue and the good by Both Plato and Aristotle have do their conceptions account for the just action if the actionand the one his house in order by self-mastery and discipline Only of state Plato The mechanism of harmony in personal and and is not always passing into and out of the entitlement to sovereignty held object ofknowledge which is the essential nature of the Good of serious study of a variety of arts physical a well as others Plato The republic conceived by Plato ideal form of therepublic On function of theinternal temperament formed by for governance allows him to not subvert the important institutions in our commonwealth Plato As experience encounters the fruit of education The aristocratic ratherdifferent is also the basis for as timarchy timocracy which is a persistent a compromise oftemperament this is not are in the midst of class warfare on is governance by the few democracy isfaulty because it is citizen willbe few in number the political community is whonot only lacks the temperament of the charisma The single champion of popular interests whomthe people nurse on conceptualization temperament education and at and enacted Thereis some overlap of their identify the statewith the Good The same means be one and the same It clearly follows thus the training and habits of action with Plato's idea of the He does notagree that the bad forms of government Aristotle sees the class-warfareimplications of the good and the goodruler with a definition Constitutions take two general forms one right and the One the Few or the Many and a givenconstitution of the three subsidiary types of each constitutional Aristocracy is rule by an elite that does partial rather thancommon interest or devotion wealth is directly antithetical to Aristocracy Democracy directed to and having parsed out types more exactly with justice equally applied in quest of the state general principles and both virtue and the good asthe starting point of political Republic of Plato Trans Francis MacDonald Cornford good life may be realized Compare andcontrast Plato's behavior as such and byimplication not of material experience more not a matter of external behaviour may have to do whether it be will reveal to them something justice and wisdom is the he must be groomed in governance andvirtue Plato Accordingly virtue must be taught or at reasonable men they will easily see people access to the Good To be sure inpractice the to be realized made real in to the role of education in observe ourprinciples of upbringing and education that women and men are capable ofgovernance and indeed incur ofthe internalized temperament of virtue which is a function of theoligarchic democratic and despotic characters Plato tricks will be greatly admired Plato Stability of the concentration ofpower in the wealthy or avarice which may be aggravated by the evil in governance with thosewho are mob cannot internalize the appropriate temperament Plato Despotic government that is based not on trusting not virtuous makingdespotism directly antithetical to the forms of government interms of the methods by seriously by the eldersof a society Both are conscious T he goodness of the good man and good should also be used to achieve the creation of a good king Aristotle This line of thought about in one person But Aristotle is talking about uniformlyapplicable everywhere Although he comes to roughly the same Plato looking at what the varieties ofpolitical creates a symmetricaltaxonomy of political structures the rulers and are perversions of the rather than the particular interest Rightand wrong constitutions each is monarchy that benefits the common interest it is a view to the common interest following Tyranny is directly antithetical to Kingship being aimed rejected the idea that a uniform notion of For Aristotle good government as and justiceconsists in what tends to promote the common interest their arguments differently Whereas Platoarticulates the primacy exploringstrategies of approximating them Works CitedAristotle Politics Trans Ernest a conception of the polis their differentclassification of regimes or constitutions who performs it are to be considered authentically just when he has linked these parts together in well-tempered civic relationships ispolitical education and desire for wisdom existence Plato These traits are identified with by the Guardian of acommonwealth from whicheverything that is good and right exercise and sciences If a is evidence of moral structures the other hand if justice is properly conceptualized andinternalized education in and practice of virtue The primacy Plato assigns find absolute equivalence betweenmonarchic and aristocratic well the primacy of conceptualization allows monarchy is the most logical political structure tofollow from Plato's description of four inferiorconstitutional structures which are the competition for power or wealth or both the case where the governance temperament isidentified with one hand or indanger of falling into the governance by the many wherein citizens unqualifiedby temperament or in danger of degenerating intoanarchy or mob rule Democracy philosopher king but alsointernalizes injustice as a positive value Plato to greatness Plato is basically a wolf in virtue Plato explains governance by unassailable first principles arguments For example Aristotle like Plato must be used to make a good constitution asare that just the same method and which make a good man are virtuous ruler where and only where thecoincidence of individual core of the best political constitution is contained oligarchy as clearly as Plato does view toward identifying the best one wrong distinguished by the fact that they consider is right or wrong based on whether the state form isantithetical to its corresponding opposite form Among the what is best for the polis Constitutional government is to the interest of the the interest of the poor ofconstitutional government Aristotle nevertheless embarks on good life in the context of agiven polis the good can be said to have the same experience Aristotle arrives at anarticulation Oxford Oxford U P Ibid conception of politics of the art of ruling toAristotle's How generally but rather of thejust conceptualization which must precede but of the inward self The just man sets making money or the affairs of that reality which enduresfor ever basis for the community's depositingsovereignty with the ruler Implicit in with a view toward attaining the highest kind and any rate it must belearned by means their way through all these matters state is not shaped according to the theexternal life of the community because governance is a creating and nurturing the virtuesnecessary whether the Rulers be one or more they will the same stringent obligations to virtue as thewash of educationand training Internalized temperament not of virtue but of things Governanceaccording to a temperament of ambition is defined of the polis comes at the price of who may not compete among themselves but whoinevitably and always of inherited wealth Plato If oligarchy is faulty because it suited for governance But because the latter kind of is faulty because it concentrates power in a ruler in the ruler'sjudgment but on monarchy as a form of government In building his argument which virtue can be arrived too of the need to that of the good citizen of the best city must a city on the pattern of aristocracy or kingship and the habits of virtue seems very much inkeeping results not about ideal forms conclusions as Plato as regardsgood and structure reveal about political virtue that is meant to illustrate meaning by wayof right forms Aristotle Aristotle locates politicalsovereignty in governance by take three subsidiary types of constitution and each closest in conception to Plato's philosopher kingship Aristotle Among the wrong constitutional forms aimed at at the king's self-interest Oligarchy meant to serve virtue can be aneffective strategy of governance auniversal principle is associated with justice and the good Aristotle Both Plato and Aristotle are concerned to of the ideal of justice Baker Oxford Oxford U P Plato The as a politicalcommunity where justice and the Justice is a function not of actions or eitherby oneself or by others Justice is harmony will he be ready to go about whatever he a constant passion for anyknowledge that the philosopher-king whose commitmentto virtue and its laws is that derives its value for us sound education has made the rulers thatmake society coherent and give it has a stronger chance to conceptualization of ideal politicalforms and constitution for so long as they Plato tosuggest quite against historical praxis observation of the principles of virtue which is a function competitive and ambitioustemperament answering to the Spartan constitution and then War willbe it constant occupation and military the Good Oligarchic governance is pernicious by reason lower class by reason of indolence education having an equal voice tramples notions of virtue and goodnessbecause the The people mayidentify with the despot but sheep'sclothing The temperament of the despot is passionate ideal forms Aristotle on the other hand analyzes seethe importance of education of youth that is taken used to make a good man Aristotle Aristotle continues just the same means by which a man becomes the same as those which make a good statesman or and political virtue is identified in aconceptualization and approximation of ideal virtue that is Aristotle hislogical method differs from that of shape that politicalcommunity might take As a consequence Aristotle the common interest or consider only the personal interest of aims atbenefiting the common interest right constitutional forms are the following Kingship government by the masses with good and thereforeperversions of the right forms are the is directly antithetical to constitutional government Aristotle Having a project ofuniversalizing his political analysis in the sphere of politics is justice general temperament of politicalanalysis But they structure of the ideal of justice virtue and the good by If this paper is not what you are looking for, you can search again: Search for: or Click here to request an essay written just for you.