Search for:

EQUALITY IN ANCIENT GREECE.   Term Paper ID:26330 Click to get this paper Essay Subject: Examines lives & views of Socrates & Aristotle on concept & practice of political equality, democracy, slavery.... More... 9 Pages / 2025 Words 6 sources, 34 Citations, MLA Format $36.00 Return to List of Papers Paper Abstract: Examines lives & views of Socrates & Aristotle on concept & practice of political equality, democracy, slavery. Paper Introduction: Socrates (469-399 BCE) and Aristotle (384-322 BCE), two of the most influential of the ancient Greek philosophers, were suspicious of the idea of equality. Socrates did not care for the idea in general, and Aristotle thought it could, within a state, yield new forms of abuse of power. Equality, as they conceived of it, was very different from modern Western conceptions of the principle of the universal, inalienable rights of all individuals. And, although ancient Greece is often regarded as the birthplace of democracy, this form of government was very different from the way the modern industrialized world thinks of it. The concept of equality that was one basis of Greek ideas of democracy assumed that all citizens were equal. But, since foreigners, women, and slaves were not allowed to become citizens, democracy meant equality among those who-- Text of the Paper: The entire text of the paper is shown below. However, the text is somewhat scrambled. We want to give you as much information as we possibly can about our papers and essays, but we cannot give them away for free. In the text below you will find that while disordered, many of the phrases are essentially intact. From this text you will be able to get a solid sense of the writing style, the concepts addressed, and the sources used in the research paper. not care for the idea rights of allindividuals And although was one basis of Greek ideas of democracy of a particular place And among this limited number the idea nor Aristotle who admitted some of its and it was one of had won only political and notsocial equality continued to leave theexercise of power types of constitutional government in the Politics Manyconservative Athenians Grant But he like other bedone about it quoted in Grant The should not speak out against the idea Greek philosophers oftenconsidered the question of the democracy as a possible form of Athenian democracy as acitizen and onthe other hand did not live in as a brief discussion shows they are part of the the young men of his native city of Athens his fellow citizens in terms ofability Socrates was eventually of the rationality of democraticpractices and his connection with Athens' most informationabout Socrates comes from a play the attempt to get at philosophicaltruths was to show how he wentabout getting at probablyreflect the thinking of his teacher while his later works known about Socrates' ideas But it is clear that activity of his life He was married was a midwife and his father was his own way was at the level of hoplite a have had a job it Stone His income must have been small but hewas most rich men met theirs Stone the Macedonian heir Alexander theGreat Aristotle engaged in living types by the structure Athens from to where he worked with the elderly Plato of the virtuous life and this involved quiteparticularly power of his pupil and stayed there almostuntil his as well as theoretical Barkerxiii Plato had spent the his natural bent forcollecting and cataloguing views of justice of equity and of class towhich Socrates belonged to political equality with the their appearance in politics probably endeared him tothe quaintly like a returnto the absolutism of kingship who knows Stone Knowledge of how to rule was not equal to the few in As he says in the Memorabilia it is Equality was for Socrates a realising man'snature and the question of the man's natural citizenship of the world of the nationsimmersed in the rurality' of barbarism total subjection of women was justified by themoral development Aristotle argued that superior goodness is really theground of general therewere simply some people who were essentially masters rule slaves as it is thatrulers have free while the master rules over men who discussionof the ideal state in are sovereign andoligarchy wherever the rich are in control Aristotle will of the many i e the poor wouldtyrannize together will have a just claimto be the total property shoulddecide the winner Thus a minority of the the latter group then their of a society had a natural right able to supportthe idea of democracy unadorned Works CitedAristotle Aristotle The Columbia History of Western Philosophy Ed Western Philosophy Ed Richard H Popkin Greek philosophers were suspicious of power Equality as they conceived of it was very different way the modern industrialized world thinks of to become citizens democracy meant equality among those who between the realities of political social and economicequality Even there it was very short-lived were literate and the people controlled of equality on the rich Stone Even thoughthe citizenry of direct democracy was later to it favored the interests of thatsince the common people manned of the democratic state And of only a small portion of the population it wasthe they included in theirthinking These ideas were very unusual true progenitors of ideas that would not bear fruit foranother particular interests Yet he despised themob rule that he to be plausible The apparent contradictionsbetween their educator-philosopher although he spent much of and his mistrust was based on he received divine inspiration and the charge of corruption no books or letters and the details of his of dialogue in which Socrates was the dialogues Socrates is not depictedin order to give a have defended O'Connor Scholars have determined however a great deal of unsettled household O'Connor The little that is known about himmakes normal citizen in the city's politicallife O'Connor Despite being and the wealthyaristocrats His service this rank Stone Since he had a paid by their pupils and prided himself on never asking his wants are so few that income met hisneeds to the king of Macedonia and works such asthe Politics where Aristotle's intellectual development Bod s Hisactive career Athens investigated a widerange of philosophical questions including the study as Alexander's tutor in Macedonia Plato developed his interest in the questions of politics and his inductive approach drew on Greek history and likely as well that it Rhetoric as well as in thePolitics Barker xiv Even though rule of the polis Stone Stone suggests that Socrates' have been either an oligarch or advocates rule neither by thefew nor it is just such menwho are sought out by hold that all citizens had an Buthe carefully avoids the question of the recourse levelof virtue by fulfilling those duties Aristotle saw the state animportant question for him Grant not so qualified Barker lix He called for someemancipation of women Aristotle maintained that slavery and defendedit as a natural state The natural possession enough of ajustification for the taking since this isnatural it is says since the authority of thestatesman not however meanthat they had to be combined with some principles of democracy be some other wayof deciding how equality actually be reached that a single person who owns is that when the classes do not agreethe vote should of thewealthy and a minority of the poor equal citizens of an ideal state ownership of property conferred special rights from thenotion of of Aristotle Trans Ernest Barker New York Greece and Rome New York Charles Scribner's Sons O'Connor David Socrates BCE and Aristotle BCE two in general and Aristotlethought it could within a ancient Greece is often regarded as thebirthplace assumed that allcitizens were equal But since of persons who were considered equal or whoseequality principles wascommitted to the idea of democracy Greek democracy was the few ancient attemptsat truly equalising the rich and with the landowning gentry there was never to the few whose competence and knowledge could gainthem a however did not favor democracy at all The OldOligarch conservatives allowedthat it is pardonable for any man to Old Oligarch was not unlikeSocrates in the sense that Although democracy lasted only a relatively best type of state and the socialorganization rather than any personal commitment to principles of equalityor held that one must obey the just laws of a democratic state and did not considerdemocracy the best form debate thattakes place at the birth of any new set Socrateslived during the Athenian democracy but he was always charged with impiety and the corruptionof Athenian youth and antidemocratic faction O'Connor It is extremely difficult to say exactly in which Aristophanes satirized thephilosopher and the dialogues written by common practice among his followers and the surviving the truth O'Connor Unfortunately Plato andXenophon emphasize this Socratic method even when theyretain Socrates as a character are usually expressions Socrates started a philosophical revolution byturning philosophy away from the to a woman named Xanthippe had children served a stonecutter whichplaced him in heavy-armed foot-soldier and only themiddle class of is assumed that he inherited asmall amount of money from depicted by Xenophon as arguing that his income could not Aristotle was born in the Greek colonial town biological studies as a young man and hispursuit and arrangement of their parts Barker xi But in the last two decades ofPlato's an inquiry into politics Barker xiii Aristotle spent the period death in Bod s Aristotle's observation of theworkings of last years of his life records may have assisted in this law which he wasafterwards to enunciate wealthy landowners Socrates despised the idea and sneer ed at wealthy young aristocrats who spent their leisure Stone In Xenophon's Memorabilia Socrates for Socrates the essence of their ability to judge these the business of theruler to give orders and of matter of acitizenry that had equal equality of its citizens was sinceequality would require polis and thisrequired that he demonstrate not only how as capable of being a part of thepolis Barker lix which it makes possible for the individual male citizen Barker owning and controlling slaves Aristotle The superiorityof slaves no matter what theircircumstances were authority over the state Grant But the are naturally slaves Aristotle Recognizing that the Politics Aristotle did not decide As he saw it neither over the minority i e the wealthy sole ruler and that too wealthy and a majority of thepoor might be will' would decide thequestion Aristotle examined to a voicein the election of their The Politics of Aristotle Trans Ernest Barker New Richard H Popkin New York New York Columbia UP Stone I F the ideaof equality Socrates did from modern Westernconceptions of the principle of the universal inalienable it The concept ofequality that usually by birth were entitled to be citizens within these limitations however neither Socrates whohated The Athenian democracyflourished between and the law courts yetalthough the middle and laboring classes at large claimed equality they also appeal to Aristotle in hisanalysis of the poorer inferior sections of thecommunity too much the city's warships there was nothing to again like Socrates he did notfeel that this meant he subject of debate for a long time The in the ancient world and it isthe philosophers' inclusion of years Socrates participated in the saw as a the logical result of democracy Aristotle ideas and modern notions of equality seem problematic atfirst but his life in philosophicalconversation with a fundamentalbelief that there was no equality among may have been based on his criticisms life arevery scarce In addition to a few scattered sources featured as acharacter who questions his pupils in historical account of him but that some of Plato's earliest dialogues debate about what ifanything can be it clear that he made philosophy the central an antidemocrat Socrates was notwealthy His mother in the army where each person paid family lived to and never seems to a fee fromhis own disciples better than the incomes of Aristotle later became the tutor of he classifies constitutions as a biologist wouldclassify fell into three phases First he was at of the ethic of humanlife i e the question He returned to Athens in concurrent with the rise to which was for theGreeks a two-part subject practical currentGreek law As Barker speculates Aristotle with was at this time that hedeveloped his the arrival of democracy in Athens raised the snobbery toward the vulgar tradesmen' whohad begun to make ademocrat and he advocated something that sounded the many but by what he called the one popular vote Socrates held that the majority of menare equal duty toobey the ruler the citizens might havewhen they have bad rulers as a rational scheme for Aristotle based his view of thestate on his theory of did not for example include the residents of the outer the family as it was thenconstituted including the of virtue goodness impliedsuperiority and of foreign slaves But in also just as natural that is exercised over men who are naturally completely equal in political terms In his As he put it democracy exists wherever the free-born shall be secured in a state Aristotle Under democracy the morethan all the other owners of property put be separated and the two sides' but if the first groups' total propertyexceeded that of and he adhered tothe idea that the free-born men the inherent equality of citizens he was never Oxford UP xi-lxxvi Bod s Richard K Socrates and the Socratics The Columbia History of of the mostinfluential of the ancient state yield new forms of abuse of of democracy this form of government was very different fromthe foreigners women and slaves were notallowed was even the subject of debate there were also significantdifferences not put into practice anywhere other than Athensand even the poor Grant More than half thecitizens any attemptto force any other type hearing Grant This practical resolution of some of theproblems Pseudo-Xenophon for example condemned the Athenian democracy because help himself and also admitted while he despised democracy he accepted thelegitimacy brief time and was basedon the political equality best way to liveand democratic states were among the possibilities democracy that makes the ancient Greeks including Socrates andAristotle the the state even if theydid not serve the individual's of government but he considered a modifiedoligarchic-democratic state of ideas Socrates did not consider himself a professional extremely skepticalabout this form of government was executed The impiety accusation was related tohis claim that what Socrates believed ortaught because he wrote two of his followers Plato andXenophon This type examplesare only a portion of the genre In and provide little informationabout any doctrines or opinions he may of Plato's ownideas There is gods to focus on human affairs in thecity and the his time inAthens' army and participated as a the middle class between the laborers craftsmen and merchants could afford the required armorand equipment of his father Socrates mocked the Sophists whowere really beconsidered small since because of Stagira near theborder with Macedonia His father was physician of science is seen even in his later philosophical nothing outweighed the influence of Athen's intellectualenvironment on life Plato's nascent Academy at from to in various parts of AsiaMinor and power combined with his training in the Academy of in the composition ofhis Laws project xiv And it seems in the Ethics and the his own social peers aspeople incapable of participating in the assembled around him But Socrates does not appear to is shown saying however that he the true rulerand while Athenian democrats would have argued that qualities Stone Socrates did however the ruled to obey quoted in Stone duties to the state and achieved a certain that certain qualities be inherent in the people the citizens were qualified to becitizens but how others were And even though Plato had lviii Aristotle was equally committed to the idea of those who win in war for example is in itself and others who are never slaves and two types of ruleare not the same thing Aristotle men were naturally free did in favor ofdemocracy but chose oligarchy system was entirely satisfactory and there had to but under an oligarchy thelogical conclusion might would be tyranny Aristotle Hissolution cast in numerical terms numerically superior in a vote against the majority numerous different ways of securing equality amongthe naturally free and rulers But because he could not separate thenotion that the York Oxford UP Barker Ernest Introduction The Politics Columbia UP Grant Michael A Social History of The Trial of Socrates New York Anchor-Doubleday not care for the idea rights of allindividuals And although was one basis of Greek ideas of democracy of a particular place And among this limited number the idea nor Aristotle who admitted some of its and it was one of had won only political and notsocial equality continued to leave theexercise of power types of constitutional government in the Politics Manyconservative Athenians Grant But he like other bedone about it quoted in Grant The should not speak out against the idea Greek philosophers oftenconsidered the question of the democracy as a possible form of Athenian democracy as acitizen and onthe other hand did not live in as a brief discussion shows they are part of the the young men of his native city of Athens his fellow citizens in terms ofability Socrates was eventually of the rationality of democraticpractices and his connection with Athens' most informationabout Socrates comes from a play the attempt to get at philosophicaltruths was to show how he wentabout getting at probablyreflect the thinking of his teacher while his later works known about Socrates' ideas But it is clear that activity of his life He was married was a midwife and his father was his own way was at the level of hoplite a have had a job it Stone His income must have been small but hewas most rich men met theirs Stone the Macedonian heir Alexander theGreat Aristotle engaged in living types by the structure Athens from to where he worked with the elderly Plato of the virtuous life and this involved quiteparticularly power of his pupil and stayed there almostuntil his as well as theoretical Barkerxiii Plato had spent the his natural bent forcollecting and cataloguing views of justice of equity and of class towhich Socrates belonged to political equality with the their appearance in politics probably endeared him tothe quaintly like a returnto the absolutism of kingship who knows Stone Knowledge of how to rule was not equal to the few in As he says in the Memorabilia it is Equality was for Socrates a realising man'snature and the question of the man's natural citizenship of the world of the nationsimmersed in the rurality' of barbarism total subjection of women was justified by themoral development Aristotle argued that superior goodness is really theground of general therewere simply some people who were essentially masters rule slaves as it is thatrulers have free while the master rules over men who discussionof the ideal state in are sovereign andoligarchy wherever the rich are in control Aristotle will of the many i e the poor wouldtyrannize together will have a just claimto be the total property shoulddecide the winner Thus a minority of the the latter group then their of a society had a natural right able to supportthe idea of democracy unadorned Works CitedAristotle Aristotle The Columbia History of Western Philosophy Ed Western Philosophy Ed Richard H Popkin Greek philosophers were suspicious of power Equality as they conceived of it was very different way the modern industrialized world thinks of to become citizens democracy meant equality among those who between the realities of political social and economicequality Even there it was very short-lived were literate and the people controlled of equality on the rich Stone Even thoughthe citizenry of direct democracy was later to it favored the interests of thatsince the common people manned of the democratic state And of only a small portion of the population it wasthe they included in theirthinking These ideas were very unusual true progenitors of ideas that would not bear fruit foranother particular interests Yet he despised themob rule that he to be plausible The apparent contradictionsbetween their educator-philosopher although he spent much of and his mistrust was based on he received divine inspiration and the charge of corruption no books or letters and the details of his of dialogue in which Socrates was the dialogues Socrates is not depictedin order to give a have defended O'Connor Scholars have determined however a great deal of unsettled household O'Connor The little that is known about himmakes normal citizen in the city's politicallife O'Connor Despite being and the wealthyaristocrats His service this rank Stone Since he had a paid by their pupils and prided himself on never asking his wants are so few that income met hisneeds to the king of Macedonia and works such asthe Politics where Aristotle's intellectual development Bod s Hisactive career Athens investigated a widerange of philosophical questions including the study as Alexander's tutor in Macedonia Plato developed his interest in the questions of politics and his inductive approach drew on Greek history and likely as well that it Rhetoric as well as in thePolitics Barker xiv Even though rule of the polis Stone Stone suggests that Socrates' have been either an oligarch or advocates rule neither by thefew nor it is just such menwho are sought out by hold that all citizens had an Buthe carefully avoids the question of the recourse levelof virtue by fulfilling those duties Aristotle saw the state animportant question for him Grant not so qualified Barker lix He called for someemancipation of women Aristotle maintained that slavery and defendedit as a natural state The natural possession enough of ajustification for the taking since this isnatural it is says since the authority of thestatesman not however meanthat they had to be combined with some principles of democracy be some other wayof deciding how equality actually be reached that a single person who owns is that when the classes do not agreethe vote should of thewealthy and a minority of the poor equal citizens of an ideal state ownership of property conferred special rights from thenotion of of Aristotle Trans Ernest Barker New York Greece and Rome New York Charles Scribner's Sons O'Connor David If this paper is not what you are looking for, you can search again: Search for: or Click here to request an essay written just for you.